Why Does Neuroplastic Pain Move, Spread, or Change?

My back was finally getting better. So why am I now struggling with migraines?

This can be one of the strangest, and most frustrating, parts of dealing with chronic pain and other symptoms. Maybe your pain started in one shoulder and eventually showed up in the other. Your back gets better, but then your hip starts hurting. A headache that used to sit behind your left eye suddenly prefers the right. Or you finally make meaningful progress with one symptom, only to have something completely different appear and immediately steal your attention.

Understandably, this can make it feel like your body is falling apart one piece at a time. Every new symptom becomes another problem to solve, another body part to investigate, another thing to Google. I know that feeling well. During my own years of chronic pain and other symptoms, there always seemed to be something new to add to the list. I had pain in multiple parts of my body, migraines, fatigue, and symptoms that changed over time, and every new development seemed to strengthen the same conclusion I had already reached: My body is not okay. When you already believe your body is fragile, a new symptom doesn’t feel like an interesting piece of information. It feels like confirmation.

Looking back, though, some of the things that scared me most about my symptoms were also some of the most interesting clues. They changed. They moved. One thing could get better while something else got louder. There were times when what my body was doing simply didn’t behave as neatly as the explanations I had been given for it. I couldn’t see that very clearly when I was living inside of it, because I was much more interested in figuring out what was wrong than admiring the oddities of my symptom pattern. Fair enough. But now, when someone tells me that their symptoms move, spread, switch sides, disappear and return, or seem to trade places with one another, I want to hear more.

Not because variability automatically means a symptom is neuroplastic. It doesn’t. But when symptoms repeatedly break the rules we expect them to follow, I think that’s worth getting curious about.

Pain doesn’t always behave like a map of damage

We tend to think about pain geographically: if my knee hurts, the problem must be in my knee. It makes sense. If smoke is coming from the kitchen, you look for the fire in the kitchen. And sometimes that reasoning is exactly right. Pain can absolutely come from injury, inflammation, nerve problems, or other medical conditions.

But pain isn’t simply a map showing us exactly where tissue damage exists. The experience of pain is produced through the nervous system, which means where we feel it, how intensely we feel it, and when it appears can be influenced by more than the condition of the tissue in that particular spot. This is one reason the behavior of a symptom can sometimes be as interesting as its location.

Maybe you’ve had severe pain in your right shoulder for three months, it disappears, and then similar pain begins in your left shoulder without a new injury. Maybe your back reliably hurts in your desk chair but somehow tolerates an airplane seat for six hours when you’re going somewhere you’re excited about. Maybe your headache moves from one side of your head to the other. Maybe a symptom that seemed completely predictable disappears for an afternoon while you’re absorbed in something else and then comes roaring back shortly after you remember to check for it. None of those things, by themselves, proves that the symptom is neuroplastic. But if our explanation is that a particular damaged structure is producing the symptom, I want to know whether the symptom actually behaves the way we’d expect that structure to behave.

This is one of the reasons I use an Evidence List with clients. We’re not trying to build a court case in which neuroplasticity wins and your body loses. We’re gathering the strange little details that are easy to dismiss when you’re frightened. Those exceptions may or may not change the conclusion, but I don’t want to throw them away just because they don’t fit the story we’ve already decided is true.

Your brain is very good at learning danger and generalizing it

If you’ve read my post What Is Neuroplastic Pain?, you know that one way I think about neuroplastic symptoms is as a learned protective response. The brain can learn that bending is dangerous, sitting is dangerous, eating a particular food is dangerous, or a certain sensation means something is wrong. And learning doesn’t always stay neatly confined to the exact thing that started it.

Imagine being bitten by a large black dog. It would make sense if you became nervous the next time you saw that particular dog. But your brain might widen the category. Maybe large black dogs start making you nervous. Then large dogs. Eventually you notice yourself tensing when you hear barking before you’ve even seen the dog. Your brain isn’t being ridiculous; it’s trying to predict danger based on what happened before. Research on chronic pain and fear learning suggests that fear can generalize beyond the original cue in some people with chronic pain, which gives us one possible way of understanding why protective responses don’t always remain attached to one perfectly defined movement, sensation, or situation.

I think the everyday version of this is more useful than getting too deep into the learning theory. One movement hurt, so you become cautious with several other movements that feel similar. One sensation scared you, so other sensations in that area start getting more attention. You spend months closely monitoring one part of your body, and your brain becomes remarkably good at noticing bodily sensations in general. None of this means the brain is literally picking pain up from your back and moving it into your knee. I think that’s too simplistic. It means that a nervous system that has become highly practiced at detecting and responding to bodily danger may not limit that protection to one exact sensation forever.

And sometimes this becomes especially noticeable when the original symptom begins to improve.

What if one symptom gets better and another one appears?

Let’s say you’ve spent months working with chronic back pain and you’re finally doing better. You’re moving more freely. You’re less afraid of the sensations. You aren’t thinking about your back every five minutes. Maybe you’ve stopped carefully testing it when you stand up or mentally taking attendance of every sensation before you get out of bed.

Then your knee starts hurting.

Great. Now I have a knee problem.

Of course that’s where your mind goes. The back has months of evidence behind it now. Your knee, meanwhile, showed up Tuesday and arrived without references.

People sometimes notice this kind of pattern during recovery: one longstanding symptom gets quieter and something else suddenly becomes much more compelling. If your nervous system has spent years becoming highly vigilant toward bodily sensations, I do think it’s reasonable to ask whether a familiar danger response might be getting attached to something new.

The tricky part is that a new symptom has an enormous advantage: you’re afraid of it. You know your back. You have evidence about your back. This thing is new. So it becomes very easy to give it everything you once gave the original symptom—monitoring, testing, Googling, protecting, worrying, and repeatedly checking to see whether it’s still there. Before long, the new sensation may become one of the most important things in your brain’s world.

That doesn’t mean the correct response is to declare every new symptom neuroplastic and carry on. If something happened that could have caused an injury, the symptom is significantly different or concerning, or medical evaluation is appropriate, you do that. Learning about neuroplasticity does not require abandoning common sense. But it also doesn’t require abandoning everything you’ve learned about your nervous system the moment your body does something weird.

This is where I want to look at the whole story

When someone I’m working with tells me, “My back is finally better, but now my hip hurts,” I’m not immediately thinking, Aha! Symptom substitution! I’m curious. When did the hip pain start? What was happening around then? Was there an injury? Does it come and go? What makes it worse? What makes it better? Does it behave anything like the symptoms we’ve already been working with? Is there anything about it that makes medical evaluation important? And perhaps most importantly, what happened inside you when you first noticed it?

That last question can tell us a lot. Sometimes a new sensation appears and within thirty seconds the person’s brain has gone from Huh, my knee hurts to Oh no, not again. What if this becomes another chronic problem? I understand that leap because I lived in a body I didn’t trust for a long time. When you’ve had enough unexplained symptoms, you can become an excellent detective who is unfortunately investigating your own body twenty-four hours a day. Every sensation becomes a clue, and none of the clues feel particularly encouraging.

What changed for me wasn’t that I eventually learned to dismiss everything my body did. It was that I stopped believing every sensation required an immediate verdict. There became room between I feel something and I know what this means. That room matters. It’s where you can ask whether you’ve seen this pattern before, whether the symptom follows the rules you’d expect it to follow, whether fear and attention are changing it, and whether there’s evidence for a neuroplastic contribution. And sometimes, of course, it’s where you decide that something is different enough that you want it medically evaluated. Curiosity isn’t denial. It’s simply refusing to decide the answer before you’ve looked at the whole picture.

This is why I especially wouldn’t interpret a new symptom as proof that recovery “isn’t working.” If you’ve already watched one symptom change as your relationship with it changed, you have something you didn’t have at the beginning. You know what it feels like when fear gets attached to a sensation. You may recognize the urge to monitor, test, protect, or immediately reorganize your life around it. You know that symptoms can be very real without always being an accurate measurement of danger. None of that proves the new symptom is neuroplastic, but it means you aren’t actually starting from scratch.

So if your back finally got better and now your hip hurts—or your migraines appeared after another symptom faded, or your pain suddenly switched sides—I don’t think the most useful question is simply, What’s wrong with this body part now? I want to know how this new symptom fits into everything that came before it.

Sometimes it is a genuinely new problem. Sometimes it looks suspiciously familiar once we start laying the pieces next to one another. And sometimes the answer isn’t obvious immediately.

That’s the part I like figuring out with people.

If your symptoms move, spread, change sides, disappear and return, or seem to break their own rules, you may also want to read How Do I Know If My Symptoms Are Neuroplastic? or use my free Neuroplastic Symptoms Self-Assessment. And if you’d like help looking at your own symptom pattern, I offer free 15-minute connect calls where we can talk about what you’ve been experiencing and whether Pain Reprocessing Therapy might make sense for you.

Schedule a Free Connect Call

About the Author

Amberleigh Maida, ICF-ACC, is an Advanced Pain Reprocessing Practitioner and life coach with training in Emotional Awareness and Expression Therapy (EAET). She also holds a master’s degree in creative writing with a focus on nonfiction. Drawing on both professional training and personal experience with chronic pain, she writes about neuroplastic symptoms, the brain-body connection, and approaches to chronic pain and other persistent symptoms.

Next
Next

Can Dizziness & Vertigo Be Neuroplastic?