Why Does Pain Flare During Recovery?

There are few things more discouraging than having a really good week and then waking up in pain again.

You were doing better. Maybe you exercised without thinking about it, sat through dinner without constantly adjusting your position, or went an entire afternoon without checking the symptom. Maybe you even had that slightly dangerous thought: Oh my gosh. Maybe this is actually working. And then, seemingly out of nowhere, you flare. Suddenly the good week doesn’t feel like evidence anymore. The flare does. I knew it wasn’t gone. I must have overdone it. What did I do wrong? Am I back at the beginning?

I understand that reaction because I remember how quickly one bad symptom day could change the entire story I was telling myself about my body. When I was dealing with chronic pain and other symptoms, I could have days that gave me real evidence that things were changing—and then one difficult day would arrive and somehow become more persuasive than everything that came before it. Apparently my brain was perfectly capable of misplacing several good days but could produce the bad one as Exhibit A within approximately four seconds. That is one reason I think understanding flares before they happen can be so helpful. A flare doesn’t automatically mean you reinjured yourself, lost your progress, or somehow failed at recovery. Sometimes it means that a nervous system that has spent a long time learning danger has not completely finished learning something new.

Recovery is rarely as neat as we would like it to be

I wish recovery looked like symptoms starting at a ten, becoming a nine, then an eight, and continuing politely downward until they reached zero and never bothered you again. That would be lovely. Brains, unfortunately, did not consult us when designing the process. When pain has become associated with particular movements, sensations, situations, or other cues, changing that pattern usually involves repeated experiences that teach something different. One safe walk can matter without immediately erasing a year of walking while afraid. Two weeks of sitting comfortably can be meaningful even if an old pain response suddenly shows up again on week three.

Research on fear learning helps explain why this can happen. When a learned fear response decreases through new learning, the original association does not necessarily vanish. Fear can sometimes return later or in a different context, and pain researchers have found similar challenges with the return of pain-related fear and avoidance after successful exposure learning. That doesn’t mean every flare is a fear-conditioning phenomenon or that we can neatly explain every symptom change this way. It does mean that the return of an old response is not the same thing as having learned nothing.  

I think of it like creating a new path through the woods. The old one is easy to find because you have walked it hundreds of times. The new path may eventually become the route you take automatically, but walking it a handful of times doesn’t cause the old trail to disappear overnight. Maybe you’ve spent two weeks sitting without much pain and your brain is beginning to learn, Sitting is safe. Then you’re exhausted, stressed, sitting somewhere unfamiliar, or you feel one unexpected twinge. The old sitting = danger path is suddenly very easy to find again. That doesn’t mean the new path was imaginary. It means both pathways still exist, and one of them has considerably more history behind it.

That distinction can be surprisingly important during recovery. If every recurrence of a familiar symptom gets interpreted as proof that you are back at square one, then every flare becomes not only a physical experience but a verdict on the entire recovery process. And that is a lot of power to give one Tuesday.

Sometimes the flare matters less than what happens next

When symptoms increase, most of us immediately want to know why. Was it the workout? Did I sit too long? Did I sleep wrong? Maybe it was stress. Maybe it was the food. Maybe I lifted something badly. Maybe I finally found the precise mistake that ruined the previous three weeks of progress. Sometimes there really is a useful explanation. People with neuroplastic pain can still overwork a muscle, catch a virus, sleep terribly, or injure themselves like everyone else. I never want the neuroplastic framework to become a reason to dismiss every physical change automatically.

But sometimes there isn’t a satisfying explanation, and the frantic search for one becomes much more interesting to me than the original increase in symptoms. Imagine waking up with your familiar pain after three really good weeks. Within ten minutes, you have mentally reviewed yesterday, checked the pain six times, tested the movement that normally bothers you, changed how you are sitting, and started wondering whether you need to cancel whatever you had planned. The symptom has been back for ten minutes and your brain has already received a fairly convincing message: This is important. We need to monitor this closely.

That is usually where I want to slow things down with someone. Not because I need them to pretend they aren’t disappointed, and not because the correct PRT response is some unnaturally cheerful Yay, pain! You are allowed to think, Oh, come on. I thought I was past this. But can that thought exist alongside something else? I’ve had three good weeks. My brain has already shown me that this can change. I don’t need to decide what this means about my entire recovery before breakfast.

This is also where an Evidence List can become incredibly useful. Flares are loud because they are happening now. Improvements are often quieter because they already happened. Maybe you stopped checking your back every time you stood up. Maybe you walked farther. Maybe the pain disappeared completely for several afternoons. Maybe you had symptoms and simply cared less about them. When those things aren’t written down, one difficult day can stroll in and rewrite the history of the previous month as if none of it happened. I have watched brains do this with remarkable confidence.

Sometimes an old response gets louder when you stop responding to it the old way

There is a concept from behavioral psychology called an extinction burst. In its traditional use, it describes a temporary increase in a learned behavior when the consequence that used to reinforce that behavior stops occurring. If you’ve ever watched a toddler ask for something, get told no, and then decide the obvious solution is to ask again seventeen times at increasing volume, you have seen the general idea in action.

I sometimes borrow that concept as an analogy for certain moments in recovery, although I’m careful not to tell someone that their pain flare has scientifically been proven to be an extinction burst. We don’t have evidence that every symptom flare during PRT works that way. What we do know is that learned fear and avoidance can return, and that older associations can remain surprisingly persistent even after new safety learning begins.  

The visual I use with clients is slightly more dramatic. Imagine two sides in a battle, and one side is beginning to lose. Instead of quietly acknowledging defeat, packing its things, and heading home, it starts firing everything it has left. Use the rest of the ammo! We’re going down swinging! For a little while, it can look much stronger than it actually is. I like the image because it reminds us not to automatically interpret “louder” as “winning.”

Of course, the context matters. If something is genuinely new, substantially different, follows a new injury, or otherwise concerns you medically, it deserves appropriate evaluation. I would never want someone to use It’s probably just a flare as a rule that overrides common sense. What I’m talking about here is the familiar symptom pattern that suddenly resurfaces in the middle of otherwise meaningful progress- the kind that has a suspicious amount in common with something your nervous system already knows very well.

A flare can become part of the recovery instead of proof against it

This is the part nobody particularly wants to hear while they are in pain, because Congratulations! What a wonderful learning opportunity! is an excellent way to make someone want to throw something at me. But a flare gives your nervous system an experience that symptom-free days cannot: what happens when the sensation comes back?

If every return of pain immediately leads to panic, testing, avoidance, researching, and the belief that your body must be damaged again, the brain gets a very familiar experience. But maybe this time the pain returns and you recognize it. You don’t necessarily like it, but it doesn’t get the same reaction. You keep the plan you already had. You move normally instead of bracing. You use somatic tracking if that genuinely helps, or maybe you realize that the last thing you need is ten more minutes of paying attention to your body and go do something else. You let the sensation be irritating without making it an emergency.

That can be new learning too. Exposure research in chronic pain has increasingly focused not just on reducing fear in one carefully controlled setting, but on helping new learning hold up across contexts and reducing the likelihood that fear and avoidance return. Real life, inconveniently, contains different chairs, stressful weeks, terrible nights of sleep, travel, workouts, illnesses, hormonal changes, arguments, and approximately four million other variables we are never going to control perfectly. Recovery has to be able to survive real life rather than only existing under ideal laboratory conditions.  

This is also why I don’t like measuring recovery only by asking whether you had pain today. Sometimes the more meaningful question is what happened because you had pain today. Were you as scared as you used to be? Did you cancel everything? Did you check it every five minutes? Did you lose the next three days trying to determine what you did wrong? Or did the symptom show up, annoy you, and eventually become one part of a day that still contained a lot of other things?

If you had pain and reacted differently to it, that counts. If a flare lasted two days instead of two weeks, that counts. If you were disappointed but not terrified, that counts. And if you had three good weeks before the flare, those weeks still count too.

When someone I’m working with has a flare, I usually don’t want to look only at the last 24 hours. I want to zoom out. What has changed over the past month? What are you doing now that you weren’t doing before? What feels less scary? What happens when symptoms show up? How quickly do you recover from them? Is this actually the same pattern you had six months ago, or does it only feel the same because pain has an impressive ability to make the present moment seem like the only evidence that matters?

So if you’re in a flare right now, I wouldn’t ask only, Why is my pain back?

I’d also ask: What does everything that happened before this flare tell me?

That question is usually much more interesting.

If you’d like support applying PRT to your own recovery, I offer free 15-minute connect calls.

Schedule a Free Connect Call

About the Author

Amberleigh Maida, ICF-ACC, is an Advanced Pain Reprocessing Therapy (PRT) Practitioner with additional training in Emotional Awareness and Expression Therapy (EAET). Having experienced and recovered from years of debilitating chronic pain herself, she brings both professional training and lived experience to her work. She also holds a master’s degree in creative writing with a focus on nonfiction. Through her writing, she explores neuroplastic symptoms, the brain-body connection, and evidence-based approaches to chronic pain and other persistent symptoms.

Learn more about Amberleigh’s personal story and approach or explore her professional credentials and training.

Previous
Previous

Can IBS Be Neuroplastic?

Next
Next

Can Neck & Back Pain Be Neuroplastic?